Sell
S9vs: 1965-2016 Here I present new research on S9V Sell signals. Below are all the cases when the V-Indicator was negative and the P-Indicator was above 0 for the dangerous time period May to September. To get an S9V, the DJI must close at least 2.4% over the 21-day ma. For testing purposes, initially no exclusion is made because of the level of ANNROC or any other key value. Upon further consideration, I believe the data below show that we can better refine S9Vs by: 1) excluding cases after 9/16 2) excluding cases where ANROC is below .170 3) excluding case where ANROC is above .648 4) excluding case where the ratio of Up Volume to Down Volume was greater than 18:1 in last 5 days. This excludes the S9V on 7/16/2009. When we make these adjustments to Sell S9Vs, we get a total of 22 cases since 1965. There are only 2 failures. In both cases, the DJI went sidewise for a month or more before making a bullish breakout. So losses here would have been limited. Date of Unrefined LA/MA ANNROC P-I P-I IP21 V-I OBV-Pct 65-day S9V Change Pct Change -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- #8 8/9/1996 1.031 .348 68 81 .107 -10 .243 .037 Failed - DJI went sidewise for a month and then broke out above flat resistance and ran upwards. --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- #20 5/18/2009 1.033 .54 334 63 -.005 -11 .047 .072 Failed - Premature... DJI went sidewise for a month and then resumed new bull market. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ All these charts are shown just below. Date of Unrefined LA/MA ANNROC P-I P-I IP21 V-I OBV-Pct 65-day S9V Change Pct Change -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 9/17/1965 (late) 1.026 .455 95 -8 .065 -8 .282 .057 Failed - DJI rallied. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- #1 6/19/1970 1.042 .954 11 63 .057 -1 .050 -.059 Success - DJI fell to lower band -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- #2 7/24/1970 1.039 .644 46 38 .024 -1 .326 -.026 Success - DJI fell to lower band -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 8/24/1970 1.029 -.143 (too low) 43 44 .111 -1 .109 .147 Failed to bring decline. DJI went sidewise for 3 months. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- #3 8/26/1971 1.041 .467 24 33 -.105 -1 .183 -.001 Success - DJI declined from 906 to 790 in 3 months. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- #4 5/26/1972 1.026 .318 0 9 .021 -1 .333 .064 Success - DJI declined almost to lower band. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ 8/14/1972 1.039 .653 (too high) 48 8 .109 -1 .121 .041 Success - DJI declined almost to lower band. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ #5 8/7/1974 1.025 .387 32 48 -.043 -1 -.004 -.057 Success - DJI fell from 800 to 580 in 2 months. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ #6 8/16/1982 1.025 .469 1 16 .119 -2 .174 -.012 Success - DJI fell slightly below lower band. ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- #7 7/18/1990 1.024 .408 15 15 .049 -4 .339 .075 Success - DJI fell from 3000 to 2360 in 3 months. ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- #8 8/9/1996 1.031 .348 68 81 .107 -10 .243 .037 Failed - DJI went sidewise for a month and then broke out above flat resistance and ran upwards. --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- #9 7/8/1998 - 1.03 .141 2 7 -.025 -17 .061 .021 Success - DJI briefly rose 2% and then fell nearly 20% in 2 months. --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- #10 6/30/1999 1.024 .417 64 44 .059 -2 .180 .096 Success - DJI briefly rose 2% and then fell to lower band. --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- #11 8/11/2000 1.026 .265 14 55 -.023 -62 .238 .063 Success - DJI briefly rose 2%-3% and then fell below lower band. --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- #12 5/17/2002 1.028 .175 51 15 -.014 -149 .081 .036 Success - DJI fell from 10200 to 7800 in 10 weeks. --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- #13 8/16/2002 1.042 .522 2 73 .134 -180 -.069 -.144 Success - DJI fell from 8700 to 7250 in 2 months. -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- #14 6/7/2004 1.03 .177 351 188 .034 -22 .028 -.019 Success - DJI fell to lower band. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- #15 9/2/2004 1.025 .194 396 70 .088 -5 .029 .008 Success - DJI fell to lower band. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ #16 5/8/2006 1.025 .388 15 25 .034 -56 .256 .067 Success - DJI fell to lower band. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ 5/16/2007 1.025 .648 (too high) 90 45 .149 -7 .627 .074 Limited Success - DJI fell to lower band, but it had risen considerably since this S9V. ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- #17 7/13/2007 1.026 .374 192 -91 .005 -15 .090 .113 Success - DJI fell back 10% in a month. ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 9/25/2007 (late) 1.025 .355 47 -117 .027 -39 .192 .031 Success - DJI did rise 4% before falling10% and marking bull market high. ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- #18 5/1/2008 1.029 .405 178 36 .047 -28 .082 .044 Success - Perfect Sell before beginning of bear market. ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- #19 8/5/2008 1.024 .403 91 136 .073 -87 .093 -.111 Success - Perfect Sell as bear market continued and DJI fell rapidly. ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- #20 5/18/2009 1.033 .54 334 63 -.005 -11 .047 .072 Failed - Premature... DJI went sidewise for a month and then resumed new bull market. ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- #21 6/3/2009 1.027 .351 221 169 .008 -96 -.018 .282 Success - DJI quickly fell slightly below lower band. ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 7/15/2009 1.028 .006 (too low) 177 221 .001 -50 -.11 .069 Failed - DJI began resumed powerful new bull market. ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 6/16/2010 1.025 -.253 (too low) 12 2 -.013 -150 -.203 -.022 Success - DJI quickly fell below lower band. ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 7/23/2011 1.031 .149 (too low) 272 96 .101 -90 .045 -.063 Success - DJI did rise 4% but then it fell below slightly lower band. --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 6/15/2012 1.026 .161 (too low) 112 106 .058 -40 -,073 -.033 Failed - DJI fell only to 21-dma and then rose for 3 months -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- #22 7/11/2013 1.028 .268 258 217 -.044 -25 .188 .053 Success - DJI fell to lower band. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 9/13/2013 1.025 .030 (too low) 31 84 -.035 -37 .016 .025 Success - DJI fell to lower band. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Current internals 1.022 .095 (too low) 216 60 .054 -59 -.094 .024
=================================================== |
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
RAW Sell S9vs 59 Sell S9vs - 1965-2001 (As I remember the necessary data only started being available in Barrons in September 1965. Some of the 1965 signals should probably be left out. This will have to be checked. ) Date DJI la/ma ann-roc P Pch IP21 VI Opct Outcome -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 7/21/2011 12724.41 1.025 .513 269 -16 .085 -51AR .005 ? (1-5) 7/5/2011 12569.87 1.037 .412 239 57 -.034 -48AR .08 declined to ma 4/27/2011 12690.96 1.025 .475 307 69 .142 0 .311 Decline below LB 2/8/2011 12333.15 1.027 .559 297 57 .166 -7 .381 1 wk higher, then decline to LB 8/9/2010 10698.75 1.025 .572 477 -19 .246 -15 .047 decline to LB 7/26/2010 10542.43 1.041 .459 442 170 .166 -11 .037 1 wk higher, then decline to LB (6-10) 11/16/2009 10406.96 1.039 .489 26 135 .001 -146 .173 2 mo up and then Decline below LB 10/22/2009 10081.31 1.026 .404 155 92 .073 -101 -.115 declined 1/2(ma+lb) 10/14/2009 10015.86 1.027 .406 246 11 .014 54 -.061 decline 1/2(ma+lb) 6/4/2009 8750.24 1.033 .478 316 92 .046 -73 .068 declined to LB 5/18/2009 8504.08 1.033 .54 335 63 -.005 -11 .045 decline to 21-dma (11-15) 8/8/2008 11734.32 1.030 .529 91 70 .088 -81 .072 crash followed Decline below LB 5/1/2008 13040.80 1.029 .405 178 36 .047 -28 .076 crash followed Decline below LB 4/3/2008 12626.03 1.031 .401 3 77 .027 -144 .021 1 mo up, then crash.Decline below LB 12/18/2007 13727.03 1.04 .416 33 50 .001 -82 .113 Decline below LB 10/2/2007 14047.31 1.032 .605 226 -87 .086 31 .257 1wk up. Then Decline below LB (16-20) 5/9/2006 11639.77 1.027 .547 110 94 .079 -6 .326 Decline below LB 12/16/2003 10129.56 1.029 .437 297 52 .039 -33 .204 LOSS.DJI rose to 10613.85 before falling below the LB to 10063.64 on 3/23/2003 3/17/2003 8141.92 1.04 .597 126 98 .117 -30 .207 LOSS.. 1 wk rally, then declined to ma at 8145.77 10/18/2002 8322.40 1.066 .581 -167 79 .037 -190 .066 LOSS.. Rallied for 6 weeks before declined to LB at 8303.78 on 12/27/2002 8/16/2002 8778.06 1.042 .522 2 73 .134 -180 -.067 w wk higher then Decline below LB (21-25) 2/25/2002 10145.70 1.031 .424 52 18 .053 -162 .023 rallied 1 month and then Decline below LB 4/17/2001 10216.73 1.041 .478 19 83 .115 -70 .175 rallied for 6 weeks and then plunged in 9/11 panic.Decline below LB 11/6/2000 10971.21 1.049 .434 -89 58 .066 -77 .032 fell to the LB 8/22/2000 11139.15 1.027 .499 108 35 .023 -5 .389 rallied 1 wk more and then Decline below LB 8/14/2000 11176.14 1.039 .403 32 18 -.004 -53 .22 rallied 2 weeks and Decline below LB (26-29) 1/14/2000 11722.98 1.03 .522 90 27 -.058 -28 .441 Decline below LB 12/28/1999 11476.71 1.026 .52 -315 1 -.052 -85 .157 fell to LB 8/23/1999 11299.76 1.04 .427 -292 66 .064 -74 -.041 Decline below LB 7/9/1999 11193.69 1.034 .555 69 39 .085 -6 .251 fell to lower band (30-35) A series of bad sells from October 98 to April 99. 4/29/1999 10173.03 1.026 .482 -7 5 -.008 -22 -.131 LOSS.. reached 11026.14 in a month before falling to LB at 10466.92 on 5/27 3/8/1999 9727.60 1.039 .539 -192 27 .052 -53 -.142 Big LOSS. 2/23/1999 9544.42 1.026 .543 -254 5 .065 -58 .04 fell to MA only. 10/22/1998 8533.14 1.061 .562 -4 -46 .06 -56 .204 Big LOSS. 12/3/1997 8032.01 1.04 .552 74 -63 .053 -16 .339 Fell to LB 2/18/1997 7067.46 1.035 .409 95 -5 .098 -3 .026 Decline below LB (36-40) 1/10/1997 6703.79 1.035 .424 102 -11 .055 -5 .318 rise for 5 weeks and then fell below LB to 6391.69 on 4/11/1997 Decline below LB 11/16/1996 6177.71 1.025 .417 45 62 .094 -3 .062 Big LOSS. 8/12/1996 5704.98 1.034 .42 76 8 .118 -7 .313 Decline to ma. 1/29/96 5304.98 1.029 .484 88 9 .198 -7 .183 Big LOSS. 11/16/95 4969.36 1.032 .475 -49 3 .11 -26 .215 Big LOSS. 3/24/95 4138.67 1.027 .40 -3 13 .137 -2 .327 Big LOSS. (41-45) 12/27/1995 3861.69 1.028 .487 4 -36 .103 -12 .243 Big LOSS. 4/16/1992 3366.50 1.032 .41 -66 -11 .072 -11 .329 up slightly for a month and then decline to LB 7/19/1990 2993.81 1.027 .41 0 -16 .065 -5 .274 Decline below LB 12/21/1987 1990.38 1.051 .599 26 55 .147 -1 .306 Fell to LB 1/7/1987 1993.95 1.033 .426 -1 157 .149 -3 .094 Big LOSS. (46-50) 12/28/1982 1058.87 1.029 .597 17 -34 -.114 -1 -.057 Fell to LB 8/20/1982 869.29 1.074 .55 -1 46 -.06 -1 -.191 Big LOSS. 7/16/1982 828.67 1.025 .469 1 16 .119 -2 .166 Fell to LB 2/13/1980 903.84 1.028 .478 -26 1 -.01 -1 .202 Decline below LB 9/14/1975 838.31 1.026 .411 -61 44 -.023 -2 .193 Fell to LB (51-55) 4/11/1975 789.50 1.033 .403 -46 37 .088 -1 -.05 LOSS. 1/2/1975 632.04 1.057 .579 -72 105 .017 -2 .247 Big LOSS. 12/27/1973 851.01 1.034 .482 -84 63 .016 -2 -.048 rose another week and then Decline below LB 8/26/1971 906.10 1.041 .467 24 33 -.105 -1 .176 rose another week and then Decline below LB 8/24/1970 759.58 1.048 .483 43 44 .111 -1 .102 Big LOSS. There is a decline to (MA+LB)/2 or 747.47 (56-59) 7/17/1970 735.08 1.053 .52 -56 34 -.011 -2 .269 Fell to LB 10/27/1966 809.57 1.045 .44 -17 44 -.023 -6 .131 Fell to (MA+LB)/2 (9/17/1965 928.90 1.026 .455 85 -8 .065 -8 .282 Big LOSS.)<1> <1>This case is excluded because ot was not based on acceptable data. |
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Superior results can be obtained for the period 1966-2011 by 1) only allowing Sell S9Vs between May and Augist. 2) requiring that the LA/MA be under 1.0425 This eliminates 2 losses (8/20/1982 and 8/24/1970) and 1 decline to the LB (17/1/70) When IP21 was above .14, a decline only to the LB was likely. 8/9/2010 10698.75 1.025 .572 477 -19 .246 -15 .047 decline to LB 7/26/2010 10542.43 1.041 .459 442 170 .166 -11 .037 1 wk higher, then decline to LB |
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
May to September Refined S9vs:
1966-2011 S9vs here occur when: 1) the DJI is 2.45% to 4.26% over the 21-dma 2) the V-Indicator 0 or less 3) and the annualized is .40 to .575 and only between May and September. The level of the P-Indicator, IP21 or ObvPct are not factored in here. Seasonality, however, is very important in making this signal useful for profitable short sales and taking profits. Results in 19 cases: 1 decline to MA and then a 2.3% paper loss. 1 decline to MA (The final outcome here is not decided. 8 declines to LB (+42.1%) 9 declines below LB (+47.4%) Conclusion: Sell S9vs add little to the Peerless system of intermediate-term signals since 1966, but they are a very useful supplemental Sell signal for traders. It may be, however that the 2011 S9vs will play out so well, that the signals should be included On an intermediate-term basis, adding them would have produced a +2.3% loss and new gains of +2.6% and 5.2%. Perhaps, the 2011 S9vs will make this signal worth adding to the regular Peerless system. The new gains from it, over and above the regular Peerless still are only marginally convincing. But for traders, who want one more way to spot a short-term reversal, the results are quite good. There is only 1 loss in 19 cases, 2.3%, and only 6 of the 19 cases had a paper loss of more than 2%. Paper Losses: There was one +3% paper loss, five +2% paper losses and one 1% paper loss. In 12 of 19 cases, the DJI fell immediately or so quickly that there was no paper loss of more than 1/2%. Date DJI la/ma ann-roc P Pch IP21 VI Opct Outcome ---------------------------------------------------------------------------- 7/21/2011 12724.41 1.025 .513 269 -16 .085 -51 .005 ?(1-5) (1-5) 7/5/2011 12569.87 1.037 .412 239 57 -.034 -48 .08 declined to ma NO PAPER LOSS Still open... 5/2/2011 12807.36 1.028 .467 212 -50 .147 -17 .33 Decline below LB in six weeks. NO PAPER LOSS There was no other Peerless sell here. Peerless Gain = +5.9% 8/9/2010 10698.75 1.025 .572 477 -19 .246 -15 .047 decline to LB There was no regular Peerless here. then decline to LB in 6 weeks. It would have gained an additional +4.0% NO PAPER LOSS 7/26/2010 10542.43 1.041 .459 442 170 .166 -11 .037 1 wk higher, There was no regular Peerless here. then decline to LB in 5 weeks.. It would have gained an additional +2.6% PAPER LOSS = 1% 6/4/2009 8750.24 1.033 .478 316 92 .046 -73 .068 Also a regular S9. declined to LB in 5 weeks..NO PAPER LOSS (6-10) 5/18/2009 8504.08 1.033 .54 335 63 -.005 -11 .045 Peerless gave a better Sell S9 on 6/4/2009 at 8750.24 Initially declined to 21-dma and then to lower band in 5 weeks PAPER LOSS = 3% 8/8/2008 11734.32 1.030 .529 91 70 .088 -81 .072 crash followed Peerless was already on a Sell S9 from 7/30/2002. Decline below LB in 6 weeks, but fell much further. NO PAPER LOSS 5/1/2008 13040.80 1.029 .405 178 36 .047 -28 .076 crash followed Also a regular S15. Decline below LB in 5 weeks,but fell much further.NO PAPER LOSS 5/9/2006 11639.77 1.027 .547 110 94 .079 -6 .326 Decline below LB Also a regular S9. Decline below LB in 5 weeks,but fell further.NO PAPER LOSS 8/16/2002 8778.06 1.042 .522 2 73 .134 -180 -.067 w wk higher Peerless was already on a Sell S9 from 8/12/2002. Decline below LB in five weeks PAPER LOSS = 2% (11-15) 8/22/2000 11139.15 1.027 .499 108 35 .023 -5 .389 rallied 1 wk more and then Decline below LB in four weeks PAPER LOSS = 2% This would have reversed the existing Peerless Buy slightly lower and earlier than Sell S4 right at the top. 8/14/2000 11176.14 1.039 .403 32 18 -.004 -53 .22 rallied 2 weeks and This would have reversed the existing Peerless Buy slightly lower and earlier than Sell S4 right at the top. PAPER LOSS = 2% Decline below LB in five weeks 8/23/1999 11299.76 1.04 .427 -292 66 .064 -74 -.041 Also a regular S9. Decline below LB in four weeks NO PAPER LOSS 7/9/1999 11193.69 1.034 .555 69 39 .085 -6 .251 Peerless was already on a Sell. Fell to lower band in 3 weeks.NO PAPER LOSS. Using Peerless to reverse this S9V would have brought a 7.1% gain. 8/12/1996 5704.98 1.034 .42 76 8 .118 -7 .313 Decline to a little below ma. Using Peerless to reverse this S9V would have brought a 2.3% loss. Here the DJI refused to breakdown and instead made a classic flat-topped breakout into all-time high territory. This is a bullish situation. The V-Indicator also turned positive for 3 weeks. This is bullish. (16-19) 7/19/1990 2993.81 1.027 .41 0 -16 .065 -5 .274 Also a regular S9. Decline below LB NO PAPER LOSS 7/16/1982 828.67 1.025 .469 1 16 .119 -2 .166 Also a regular S9. Fell to LB NO PAPER LOSS 9/14/1975 838.31 1.026 .411 -61 44 -.023 -2 .193 Also a regular S9/S12. Fell to LB NO PAPER LOSS 8/26/1971 906.10 1.041 .467 24 33 -.105 -1 .176 Rose another week and then Decline below LB in 8 weeks. PAPER LOSS = 2% Also an S9 on 8/17/71 and regular S12 on 8/23/1971 and 8/31/71. Eliminated because of DJI being too far above the 21-dma: LA/MA 8/20/1982 869.29 1.074 .55 -1 46 -.06 -1 -.191 Big LOSS. 8/24/1970 759.58 1.048 .483 43 44 .111 -1 .102 Big LOSS. There is a decline to (MA+LB)/2 or 747.47 7/17/1970 735.08 1.053 .52 -56 34 -.011 -2 .269 Fell to LB |
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||